An educational and research-based examination of what happens when a copyright-protected work remains valuable for society, but the person who owns the rights cannot be identified or located.
Copyright law is designed to protect creativity, encourage the production of knowledge and safeguard the economic and moral interests of authors and other rights holders. Yet copyright can create a difficult practical problem when a valuable work survives while information about its owner disappears. A book may remain in an archive, a photograph may be preserved in a museum, a manuscript may sit in a library collection, or an old recording may remain historically important, but the person who owns the copyright may be impossible to identify or find.
This situation is commonly described as the orphan works problem. It is not simply a question of whether a work is old. A work can be old and still protected by copyright. The difficulty is that the person who has the legal authority to authorize a particular use cannot be identified or located after reasonable efforts.
The issue has become more important as libraries, archives, universities, museums and other institutions increasingly digitize their collections. Digital technology makes it possible to preserve fragile material and share knowledge with researchers and the public. At the same time, copying, publishing or communicating protected material can raise copyright questions.
This article examines that question from an Ethiopian perspective and discusses the comparative approaches considered in the research of Solomon Fikadu Gilo. The study examines Ethiopia alongside selected approaches from the European Union, the United Kingdom, Canada and the United States.
Understanding the Meaning of an Orphan Work
The term orphan work describes a situation in which a copyright-protected work has no readily identifiable or locatable rights holder. In other words, the work itself may be known, its author may sometimes be known, and its historical or educational value may be obvious, but the person or entity with authority to grant permission cannot be identified or located.
An orphan work is a work that may still be protected by copyright but whose rights holder cannot be identified or located after a diligent and reasonable search.
The distinction between an orphan work and a public-domain work is extremely important. A work does not automatically enter the public domain merely because nobody knows where the copyright owner is. Copyright may continue to exist even when ownership information is incomplete.
For example, imagine that an Ethiopian archive holds a collection of photographs taken many decades ago. The photographs are clearly identifiable, but the original photographer cannot be located and there is no reliable information showing who currently owns the copyright. The archive may want to digitize the photographs and make them available to researchers. The photographs could be orphan works if the necessary conditions are satisfied.
The same issue can arise with books, newspapers, manuscripts, paintings, films, sound recordings, maps, illustrations, music and other creative works.
Why Orphan Works Create a Copyright Problem
Copyright gives authors and other rights holders legal control over important uses of their protected works. The exact rights depend on the applicable law and the type of work, but copyright can include rights relating to reproduction, distribution, communication and other forms of exploitation.
Normally, a person who wants to make a use requiring authorization can contact the rights holder and request permission. The orphan works problem begins when that ordinary process breaks down.
The user may have made serious efforts to find the owner and still be unable to establish who has authority to give permission. At that point, the user faces uncertainty.
The copyright owner’s interest
A rights holder should not lose copyright simply because the person or institution seeking permission has difficulty finding them. A creator or successor may still have legitimate economic and moral interests in the work.
The public interest
Society also has legitimate interests in education, research, cultural preservation, historical documentation and access to knowledge. These interests become particularly important when institutions preserve materials that might otherwise disappear.
The difficulty is therefore not solved simply by choosing one side. A good legal framework needs safeguards for rights holders while providing a realistic path for legitimate users.
Without such a pathway, institutions may avoid using orphan works altogether. This can create a situation in which material remains locked inside archives even though digitization and responsible access would provide significant public benefit.
How Do Works Become Orphaned?
There is no single cause behind the orphan works problem. The research identifies several factors that can make rights information increasingly difficult to trace over time.
Automatic copyright protection
Modern copyright systems generally provide protection without requiring an author to complete a formal registration process before protection begins. This is important because it allows creators to receive protection without unnecessary administrative barriers.
However, when registration is not necessary, there may be no single authoritative public record containing complete information about every protected work and its current owner. Over time, this can make rights clearance more difficult.
Long periods of copyright protection
Copyright can continue for many years. During that period, authors may die, businesses may close, publishers may disappear, organizations may merge and families may relocate.
The longer the period between creation and proposed reuse, the greater the possibility that contact information and ownership records will become incomplete.
Transfers and inheritance
Copyright ownership can change. Rights may be assigned, transferred, licensed or inherited. A person attempting to identify the current owner may therefore need to trace the history of the rights rather than simply identify the original author.
The research specifically recognizes transfer of rights and inheritance as factors that can complicate the process of identifying the person entitled to authorize use.
Joint ownership
Some works involve multiple authors or rights holders. When several people share rights, locating every relevant person can become difficult.
Joint ownership can therefore increase the possibility that at least one rights holder cannot be identified or located.
Technological change
Technology has transformed the way creative works are stored and used. Material that once remained inside a physical collection can now be scanned, photographed, digitized, indexed and distributed electronically.
This creates enormous opportunities for education and preservation, but it also increases the need for clear copyright rules because digitization normally involves making copies of works.
Copyright Protection in Ethiopia
The Ethiopian copyright framework examined in the research is primarily based on the Copyright and Neighboring Rights Protection Proclamation No. 410/2004, together with the subsequent amendment identified in the study.
The Ethiopian Intellectual Property Authority identifies Proclamation No. 410/2004 and Copyright and Neighboring Rights Protection Amendment Proclamation No. 872/2014 among Ethiopia’s copyright laws and regulations.
The Ethiopian framework protects a broad range of literary and artistic works. This includes categories such as books, articles, computer programs, musical works, audiovisual works, photographs, maps and other protected creations.
The law also recognizes economic rights and moral rights. Economic rights are particularly important when considering orphan works because a person seeking to reproduce, publish or otherwise exploit a protected work normally needs to determine who has the relevant authority.
Copyright duration matters
The question of whether a work is still protected cannot be answered merely by saying that the work is old. The relevant copyright term must be considered according to the category of work and the applicable legal provisions.
The Ethiopian Intellectual Property Authority states that under Proclamation No. 410/2004, copyright generally continues during the author’s lifetime and for 50 years after death for heirs or legatees, while certain categories of works are subject to specific terms.
This makes rights-status analysis an important part of any responsible orphan works process.
The Orphan Works Legal Gap in Ethiopia
The central issue identified by the research is that Ethiopia does not have a specific and comprehensive legal mechanism dedicated to orphan works comparable to the specialized mechanisms examined in the selected jurisdictions.
This is important because ordinary copyright provisions may not answer every practical question faced by an archive, library, museum, university or other organization that has completed a serious search and still cannot find the rights holder.
The absence of a dedicated framework can create uncertainty. An institution may know that a work is historically valuable and may have evidence showing that considerable effort was made to identify the owner, but it may still be uncertain about the legal consequences of using the work.
This issue becomes more significant as Ethiopia expands digital libraries, electronic archives, cultural preservation projects and online educational resources.
A clear orphan works framework could provide institutions with a structured process instead of forcing each organization to resolve the problem independently.
The European Union Model
The European Union provides an important example of a structured legal response to orphan works.
The research explains that different possible solutions were considered, including extended collective licensing, a specific orphan works licensing system and a statutory exception. The EU ultimately adopted a statutory exception-based approach.
Why a statutory exception?
The basic logic is that certain qualifying uses can be permitted when the conditions established by law have been satisfied. This approach does not simply declare the work free from copyright. Instead, it creates a controlled legal route for specified institutional uses.
A central safeguard is the requirement for a diligent search. Before an institution can rely on the orphan works mechanism, it must make reasonable efforts to identify and locate the rights holder.
The research notes that the EU considered extended collective licensing but identified limitations, including the difficulty of dealing with works for which no positive orphan determination had been made and the absence of a comparable upfront diligent-search requirement.
The EU experience demonstrates that a statutory exception can be designed to balance access and copyright protection rather than simply choosing one over the other.
The United Kingdom Model
The United Kingdom provides a more diversified approach. The research considers mechanisms that include certain permitted uses, licensing of orphan works and extended collective licensing.
Permitted institutional uses
Certain institutions can make qualifying uses of orphan works when the statutory conditions are satisfied. This can be important for organizations whose public-interest functions include preservation, research and access.
Orphan works licensing
The UK licensing approach provides a route for obtaining permission to use a qualifying orphan work after the applicant has completed the required search process.
This is particularly relevant where the intended use requires a formal authorization rather than reliance on a broad exception.
Why this matters for Ethiopia
The UK example demonstrates that different users may need different solutions. A museum preserving historical photographs may not have the same needs as a commercial publisher seeking to reproduce a photograph in a commercial publication.
A flexible Ethiopian system could therefore distinguish between institutional preservation and commercial exploitation.
The Canadian Model
Canada provides another approach through licensing involving the Copyright Board.
The significance of this model is institutional. Instead of leaving the user to decide alone whether a work should be treated as orphaned, the system provides a process through which an applicant can seek authorization when the copyright owner cannot be located.
Such a model can be attractive because it provides a formal decision-making mechanism. It also creates an administrative record that can improve transparency.
For Ethiopia, the Canadian experience raises a practical question about institutional capacity. If a dedicated authority were given responsibility for orphan works, it would need appropriate procedures, expertise, records and resources to evaluate applications effectively.
The United States Model
The United States approach examined in the research is different from the statutory exception models discussed above.
Limited liability
One approach considered in the US context is to reduce the potential liability of a person who has made a reasonable effort to locate the rights holder but remains unable to do so.
The underlying policy concern is straightforward: a user may be willing to respect copyright but should not necessarily face disproportionate consequences when the owner cannot be found despite reasonable efforts.
Fair use
The research also examines fair use. Fair use is evaluated through factors that include the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the copyrighted work, the amount used and the effect of the use on the potential market.
Fair use can provide flexibility for certain educational, research and public-interest activities. However, it is highly dependent on the facts of each case and therefore does not necessarily provide the same predictability as a dedicated licensing system.
What the International Comparison Shows
The comparative jurisdictions do not use one identical solution. Instead, they demonstrate several possible ways of balancing rights protection with access.
| Jurisdiction | Approach discussed | Important policy lesson |
|---|---|---|
| European Union | Statutory exception for qualifying uses following required conditions and diligent search. | A clear statutory pathway can facilitate preservation and public-interest access while maintaining safeguards. |
| United Kingdom | Permitted institutional uses, licensing and extended collective licensing. | Different mechanisms can address different users and types of use. |
| Canada | Institutional licensing through the Copyright Board. | A dedicated decision-making body can provide greater legal certainty. |
| United States | Limited-liability concepts and fair-use analysis. | Flexible liability and copyright doctrines can reduce barriers but may provide less certainty. |
The comparison does not mean that Ethiopia should copy another country’s law word for word. Ethiopian legislation must reflect Ethiopia’s own legal system, institutions, cultural priorities and administrative capacity.
The real value of comparative research is that it identifies policy choices that Ethiopian lawmakers and institutions can consider when developing an appropriate national framework.
Lessons Ethiopia Can Draw From Other Jurisdictions
The most important lesson is that the orphan works problem can be addressed without abandoning copyright protection.
A well-designed framework can recognize that a rights holder deserves protection while also acknowledging that society should not lose access to valuable works merely because the rights holder has become impossible to locate.
Diligent search should be the foundation
A user should not be allowed to label a work an orphan work simply because a quick internet search produced no result.
A diligent search should involve reasonable investigation of relevant sources. Depending on the type of work, this could include library catalogues, publisher records, author information, archives, rights-management organizations, institutional records and other reliable sources.
The search should be documented
Documentation is important because it provides evidence that the user genuinely attempted to locate the rights holder.
A responsible institution should keep a record of what was searched, which sources were consulted, which organizations were contacted, the dates of the searches and the results obtained.
Commercial and non-commercial uses can be treated differently
A commercial publisher and a public archive may have different legal and policy needs. A future Ethiopian framework could therefore create different routes depending on the purpose and character of the proposed use.
For example, non-commercial preservation by a qualifying cultural institution could be subject to a carefully defined exception, while commercial exploitation could require a licence issued through a designated authority.
Possible Legal Solutions for Ethiopia
Based on the comparative approaches examined in the research, Ethiopia could consider a combination of mechanisms rather than relying on a single solution.
The goal of these reforms would not be to make copyright irrelevant. Instead, the purpose would be to reduce unnecessary uncertainty where the normal permission process has failed because the rights holder cannot be found.
Orphan Works in the Digital Age
Digitization has changed the orphan works debate because it creates both a solution and a new legal challenge.
A physical archive may contain thousands of documents that are difficult for researchers to access. Digitization can protect those materials from physical deterioration and allow researchers to discover information without handling the original objects repeatedly.
However, digitization generally involves reproduction. If the underlying material remains protected by copyright, an institution needs a legal basis for making the digital copy and potentially for making it available to the public.
Libraries
Libraries preserve books, newspapers, photographs, manuscripts and other information resources. A clear orphan works framework could help libraries manage older collections where ownership information is incomplete.
Archives
Archives are especially important because they preserve records of historical events, institutions and communities. Many archival collections contain materials created under conditions in which detailed rights metadata was never maintained.
Museums
Museums may preserve photographs, artworks, recordings, catalogues and other cultural materials. Digital exhibitions can increase access, but copyright uncertainty can limit how much of a collection can be displayed online.
Universities and researchers
Researchers often need to consult historical sources that are difficult to access. A predictable legal framework can help universities and researchers understand when and how protected material may be used.
A Practical Rights-Clearance Process
Until a comprehensive orphan works framework is established, users should approach potentially protected works cautiously. The following process can help organize a responsible rights-clearance exercise.
About the Researcher
Solomon Fikadu Gilo
The research discussed in this article is based on the LL.M. study titled “Addressing ‘Orphan Works’ Problem under the Ethiopian Copyright Regime: Lesson from Other Jurisdictions.”
The research was prepared at Haramaya University, College of Law and examines the orphan works problem from the perspective of Ethiopian copyright law while drawing comparative lessons from the European Union, the United Kingdom, Canada and the United States.
The study examines the causes of orphan works, the legal challenges created by untraceable rights holders, comparative approaches and possible recommendations for the Ethiopian copyright framework.
The value of the research lies in its focus on a practical copyright problem that becomes increasingly important as digital technology changes how historical and cultural materials are preserved, reproduced and accessed.
Key Points to Remember
- An orphan work is not automatically a public-domain work.
- The central problem is the inability to identify or locate the copyright owner after a reasonable search.
- Automatic protection, long copyright terms, transfers of rights, inheritance, joint ownership and technological change can contribute to orphan works.
- Ethiopia has a general copyright framework, but the research identifies a need for a more specific and comprehensive orphan works mechanism.
- The European Union demonstrates how a statutory exception can create a controlled pathway for qualifying institutional uses.
- The United Kingdom demonstrates the possibility of combining exceptions and licensing mechanisms.
- Canada demonstrates the use of an institutional licensing process.
- The United States demonstrates the relevance of limited-liability approaches and fair-use analysis.
- Diligent search should be an important safeguard in any Ethiopian orphan works system.
- A future framework could distinguish between commercial exploitation and non-commercial preservation, education and research.
Frequently Asked Questions About Orphan Works
What exactly is an orphan work?
An orphan work is generally a copyright-protected work whose rights holder cannot be identified or located after a diligent and reasonable search.
Does an unknown copyright owner mean that the work is free to use?
No. The inability to locate a rights holder does not by itself mean that copyright has expired or that the work can automatically be used without permission.
Why are orphan works important in Ethiopia?
They are important because Ethiopia has historical, cultural, educational and documentary collections that can benefit from preservation and digitization. Copyright uncertainty can make responsible reuse more difficult when rights holders cannot be located.
What is a diligent search?
A diligent search is a serious and reasonable effort to identify and locate the copyright owner. A strong legal framework should specify the sources and procedures that should normally be used.
Why do libraries and archives face the orphan works problem?
Libraries and archives often hold older collections created by many different authors and organizations. Ownership information may be incomplete, especially where records are old, rights have changed hands or original creators are no longer reachable.
Can digitization make the orphan works problem worse?
Digitization does not create the underlying ownership problem, but it makes the issue more visible because digitization normally involves reproduction. Institutions therefore need a clear legal basis for copying and making protected works available.
What could Ethiopia learn from the European Union?
One important lesson is the possibility of creating a statutory exception for qualifying uses, combined with safeguards such as a diligent-search requirement.
What could Ethiopia learn from the United Kingdom?
The UK demonstrates that different mechanisms can be combined. Certain institutional uses can be treated differently from commercial uses that may require licensing.
What could Ethiopia learn from Canada?
Canada demonstrates the potential value of an institutional licensing process in which an authority reviews applications where the rights holder cannot be located.
What could Ethiopia learn from the United States?
The US discussion highlights approaches based on liability limitation and fair-use analysis, showing how flexibility can sometimes reduce the risks faced by users.
Conclusion
The orphan works problem is ultimately a problem of legal uncertainty. The work exists, copyright may still exist, and society may have a genuine reason to preserve or access the work, but the person who can authorize its use cannot be found.
For copyright owners, this situation should not become a shortcut through which others can freely exploit protected works. A creator’s rights should not disappear merely because contact information has been lost.
At the same time, society should not be forced to treat every untraceable work as practically unusable forever. Historical photographs, manuscripts, recordings, books and other cultural materials can have enormous value for education, research and preservation.
The comparative experience examined in the research demonstrates that there are several possible ways to address this tension. The European Union has developed a statutory exception approach. The United Kingdom combines different mechanisms, including licensing. Canada provides an institutional licensing model. The United States offers lessons from limited-liability concepts and fair-use analysis.
These approaches provide useful policy options, but Ethiopia does not need to reproduce any foreign system exactly. A future Ethiopian framework should be designed around the country’s own copyright objectives, institutions, cultural collections and administrative capacity.
A particularly useful approach could combine a clear definition of orphan works, a carefully designed diligent-search requirement, transparent record-keeping, licensing for appropriate commercial uses and limited exceptions for qualifying libraries, archives, museums and educational institutions.
Such a system could protect copyright while also supporting the preservation and responsible use of Ethiopia’s documentary and cultural heritage.
The larger lesson is simple: copyright protection and public access do not have to be permanent enemies. With carefully designed rules, it is possible to protect the legitimate interests of creators and rights holders while creating a responsible pathway for society to preserve and learn from works whose owners can no longer be found.
Read the Full Research Paper
Access the complete research paper by Solomon Fikadu Gilo for a detailed examination of orphan works under the Ethiopian copyright regime and lessons from other jurisdictions.
Download Full Research Paper (PDF)For readers looking for a broader collection of Ethiopian federal proclamations and legal materials, you can also explore our FDRE Proclamations 2021 . This can be useful for students, researchers and legal professionals who want to consult additional Ethiopian legislative materials.

